What’s the Hurry?

Post image for What’s the Hurry?

by Felice on August 28, 2009

I have had a few good friends ask me to write about a commercial that claims to teach babies to read.  When I watch this commercial, it makes me feel like I am watching a circus act.  Honestly what is the damn hurry?

Instead of turning  kids into a circus act, little kids should be learning how to love reading.  In my home we make sure our kids read before bed, sometimes we read side by side, and sometimes they are alone.  I am in mother/daughter book clubs with both girls, we go to bookstores and libraries, and somehow without the magic of an expensive program, both kids love to read. I mean really like getting cozy with a good book, and getting lost in the story and characters.

I'll never forget a first grade parent teacher conference for my then 1st grader. The teacher asked me what  kind of teacher would I like my daughter to have the following year - one that emphasized more math, more art etc. I said "I don't know, I just want my kids to be nice people in the world."  I thought she would fall off the chair. I am sure she was not used to that answer. But it's the truth. I want a teacher that, along with the academics, will help them  continue to do the right thing, and make good choices. You can be the smartest person on the planet, but if you don't know how to live by the golden rule, all those brains won't get you very far.

The bigger issue I see is why do parents feel the need to push kids to do be the first to do everything.  At my youngest daughter's back to school haircut, there was a SEVEN YEAR OLD getting hot pink streaks put into her angelic blond hair. This weekend I saw a TEN YEAR OLD boy with a huge "diamond" stud earring. There are parents driving hours away from their neighborhood to go to "the best" dance school/music teacher/pitching coach. Must we push them to excel at  everything?

Instead of Baby Can Read, how about "Everyone is on their own time schedule for reading, writing, toilet training, staying home alone, driving, and let's honor what works for each kid instead of pushing them to be the first" - but I guess that would make a very long title for a book or video.

What do you think?

Photo by - betsssssy
  • Share/Bookmark
  • kathy lipschutz
    I totally agree, I think they are goin gto start teaching kids in the embryo and expecting cursive writing in kindegarden. Too much pressure for these kids and parents!!!
  • Wendy
    As a Head Start teacher for nearly 15 years I whole-heartedly agree! While reading skills are a key indicator of future school success, the ability to get along with others and the desire to learn and grow will take you a long way in this world.

    Children should be allowed and encouraged to grow and develop at their own pace as individuals, not pushed or rushed. As parents and teachers we need to watch and listen to our children, then help them to discover who they are; build upon their interests, talents and strengths and provide support and encouragement along the way.

    We want the best for our children and often feel we know what that is - ultimately our children have to determine what is the best for them and have the strength, courage, and desire to pursue their own dreams - not ours.
  • Vicky Kulikov
    Felice,

    You are spot on! Thanks to your husband for sharing this on facebook.
  • Allyson
    I totally agree! This "Baby Can Read" thing makes me crazy. What is the point? Really? Babies are not supposed to read. They're supposed to be..... BABIES!
  • Thanks friends -it's nice to know I am not alone.
  • barrieraffel
    I think this could go under the heading "just say no". If only we all tried to get a jump start on empathy and kindness instead but everything unfolds in it's own time. good blog!
  • Right, as always, Felice. The innate curiosity and inquisitiveness of children IS the joy...it doesn't have to lead to any thing or have a measurable impact. But I think it takes an awful lot of confidence to say, "when my daughter is poking that roly poly with a stick, she's LEARNING! When she spends the day trying to make a birdhouse out of an old piece of cardboard she's LEARNING!"

    We've been socialized, especially since No Child Left Behind, that the results matter more than the process. Nothing could be farther from the truth. I think honoring who the child is..the essence of the child - warts & all - is the greatest gift we can give them.

    Thanks for sparking such an awesome discussion!
  • Julie
    Hallelujah! AFter our conversation the other day, I was thinking that this also feeds on our fear/guilt as moms: "What if I don't buy the video series for my one-year-old, and then my child doesn't read? It'll be all my fault!" Mothering is scary work -- there's sooo much at stake! -- and merchandise (propaganda?) like this only feeds into our fears. Why doesn't someone write about those products and the HARM that they do?!

    Like you, my dreams and hopes for my children are simple: grow up to be loving, peaceful people who respect the earth and its inhabitants. I think that's what most people want for their kids, but it's easy to get lost in the "noise" of consumerism. It's good, then, to surround ourselves with friends (like you) who have similar values and who remind us what ultimately matters. xoxo
  • Victoria
    Amen, Felice. I couldn't agree with you more!
blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: